New York Sexual Abuse Lawsuits
Since its passing of the Child Victim’s Act in August of 2019, New York is noted for being one the most victim friendly states in the country with regards to sexual abuse and assault laws. Its efforts to change legislation has helped survivors of sexual abuse get justice against their abusers in the courts, and also allows for compensation. These laws enable lawyers handling sexual abuse claims in New York to file cases against sexual predators, including clergy members, and the Catholic church.
Below you will find New York Lawsuits News & Updates, as well as additional information on New York’s statute of limitations laws. These laws are important because they dictate how long a lawyer handling New York sexual assault cases has to file a claim on behalf of a survivor. In addition, we’ve compiled a list of New York’s settlements and jury awards received by sexual abuse and assault survivor and a list of New York’s ‘credibly’ accused priests released by the dioceses.
New York Statute of Limitations for Sexual Abuse & Assault
New York’s original reform of its child sexual abuse laws, dubbed The Child Victims Act, was instrumental in helping many sexual abuse survivors pursue justice against their abusers. While the revival windows opened by the CVA have since closed, New York continues to make further efforts to reform its criminal and civil child sexual abuse SOL laws.
Criminal Statute of Limitation Laws for New York
In 2019 New York made several improvements to its criminal statute of limitation laws. It removed the SOL for 1st degree incest, moved the age to 43 for rape and criminal sexual acts in the 2nd degree, and 33 for those in the 3rd degree. All other felonies have a SOL of age 28 and misdemeanors is age 25. New York has continued its efforts to improve criminal SOL laws by introducing more bills to further help sexual abuse survivors. Child USA, who has evaluated every state based on their criminal statute of limitation laws, gave New York a Criminal SOL score of 3, on a 1-5 scale, where 5 is the highest. A score of 3 is defined as a criminal SOL eliminated for felonies only.
Civil Statute of Limitation Laws for New York
In New York, the civil SOL for child sex abuse is capped at age 55 against any type of defendant. However, the state does not have any type of discovery rule which could be applied to child sex abuse claims. Even though the state’s original revival window has closed, there is pending legislation which would open another 3-year revival window for all expired claims, including those governed by another jurisdiction. There is also a bill specific to New York City which is waiting for the Mayor’s approval which would open a 2-year window in New York City for gender-motivated violence, including sexual assault of children and adults.
Child USA, who has also evaluated every state based on their civil statute of limitation laws, gave New York a Civil SOL Age Cap score of 4, on a 1-5 scale, where 5 is the highest. A score of 4 is defined as a civil SOL age cap for survivors age 50 and older. Additionally, Child USA gave New York a related SOL Revival Law score of 4 on the same 1-5 scale. A score of 4 is defined as a revival window for 2 or more years or revival up to age 55, for claims against all defendants.
If you or someone you love was sexually abused or assaulted in New York, contact us now. Due to New York’s current laws and pending legislation, those sexually abused as a minor could still have a claim against their abuser, depending upon how long ago the abuse occurred. Even if the abuser is deceased, you may still have a claim against the organization responsible. Don’t wait to file your claim.
Go to our main sexual abuse page to learn more about the process of filing a sexual abuse claim.
New York Sexual Abuse Settlements & Jury Awards
It is estimated that the Dioceses within New York state have collectively paid out over $100 million to survivors of childhood sexual abuse at the hands of its clergy. Below outlines the timeline of some of those settlements.
May 2007 – A jury in Long Island awarded two survivors $11,450,000 after hearing testimony related to rape by their former youth minister starting in the late 1990s. The jury found the Diocese of Rockville Centre, St. Raphael’s Church in East Meadow and its pastor all negligent in hiring Matthew Maiello . Maiello later served two years in prison for statutory rape related to the two victims.
2016 – 2019 – According to the New York Archdiocese, its compensation fund, set up for sex abuse victims, paid out $65,000,000 to over 300 victims from 2016 to August of 2019.
September 2018 – The Brooklyn Diocese reached a settlement with 4 boys for $27,500,000 who were abused by Angelo Serrano beginning in 2003. The abuse was said to have happened over a six-year span and occurred at St. Lucy-St. Patrick Church offices, Serrano’s apartment and a brick schoolhouse converted to low-cost housing by Catholic Charities. In 2011 Serrano was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
May 2019 – The Diocese of Buffalo paid $17,500,000 to over 100 victims of clergy sexual abuse. The payments ranged from $2000 to $650,000 depending on the severity and length of the abuse.
September 2019 – The Roman Catholic Diocese of Rochester filed for Chapter 11 Bankruptcy after a number of sexual abuse lawsuits were filed against them. According to a New York Times article, the Rochester Diocese has assets estimated between $50-100 million, while its financial liabilities range from $100-500 million. That said, typically in order for a court to approve the bankruptcy, a settlement fund will need to be created, and adequately funded by the diocese for current and future sexual abuse survivors.
*The settlements listed above are offered for educational purposes only and do not guarantee any future outcome or settlement. Each legal situation is different, and past performance does not guarantee future results. We do not maintain that is a full list of all settlements in the state of New York but merely a grouping of those we choose to share on our website. Please contact us if you would like additional settlements included or if you notice any inaccuracies on our site. We strive to provide our viewers the most up to date and accurate information as possible.
New York Catholic Dioceses Release Names of Clergy Credibly Accused of Sexual Abuse of Children
The Archdiocese of New York has released the following list of priests, deemed to have been credibly accused of sexual abuse of a minor. According to their website:
“credibly accused” means that archdiocesan officials have determined, following a review of available and accessible files, that one or more of the following exists:
- the archdiocesan Review Board found the allegation to be credible and substantiated;
- the accused was laicized or permanently removed from ministry as a result of the allegation;
- the accused admitted the allegation;
- the accused was convicted of a crime in connection with the allegation; or
- there was a civil settlement as a result of the allegation prior to the creation of the Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program.
For cases where the priest listed to not meet the criteria for ‘credibly accused’, or a final decision has not yet been made, the Independent Reconciliation and Compensation Program (IRCP) may have determined the claims made against a particular priest were eligible for compensation. For those in this category, please note:
- The clergy with that categorization had already died or left ministry when the claims about them were made to the IRCP. As such, these clergy did not have an opportunity to respond to the allegations made about them or provide a defense.
- While the IRCP is a widely praised program and being emulated across the country, it is a compensatory program and not an adjudicatory body. As such, it is not required to adhere to the same standards as a court of law.
- A determination by the IRCP that a claim is eligible for compensation is not equivalent to a finding by a judge or jury that a clergy member is liable for sexual abuse of a minor under civil or criminal law.
- Certain archdiocesan clergy members who are on the list below were also the subject of eligible IRCP compensation claims.
Archdiocese of New York Credibly Accused Priest List
|wdt_ID||Last Name||First Name||Year of Ordination/ Incardination||Clergy Status||Archdiocese Categorization|
|1||Adamo||Joseph||1942||Removed from ministry; deceased 2003||Credibly Accused|
|2||Albino||John||1990||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|3||Ansaldi||Joseph||1962||Deceased 2015||Only IRCP's independent administrators have detemined that claims against them were eligible for compensation|
|4||Barjacoba||Peter||1960||Removed from ministry; deceased 2012||Credibly Accused|
|5||Betances- Torres||Martin||1987||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|6||Boyle||Francis V.||1955||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|7||Brady||John J.||1908||Deceased 1950||Only IRCP's independent administrators have detemined that claims against them were eligible for compensation|
|8||Brennan||Robert J.||1949||Removed from ministry; deceased 2008||Credibly Accused|
|9||Calabrese||Daniel||1987||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|10||Carbo||Richard||1975||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|11||Carden||Robert||1957||Removed from ministry; deceased 2008||Credibly Accused|
|12||Carroll||Maurice||1956||Deceased 1998||Only IRCP's independent administrators have detemined that claims against them were eligible for compensation|
|13||Carson||David||1984||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|14||Carson||John F.||1964||Deceased 2011||Credibly Accused|
|17||Coen||Charles||1968||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|18||Colleran||Kevin||1972||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2016||Credibly Accused|
|24||Dickson||Donald (Deacon)||1979||Removed from ministry 2005, deceased 2005||Credibly Accused|
|25||Dobransky||Edward||1959||Left ministry; deceased 2017|
|26||Dougherty||Daniel M.||1927||Deceased 1978|
|27||Duenas||Jaime||1950||Removed from ministry; deceased 2014; laicization process pending at death||Credibly Accused|
|28||Eremito||Anthony J.||1967||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|29||Fennessy||Keith||1984||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|32||Flanagan||John D.||1973||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|35||Gallagher||Kevin||1998||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|36||Gallant||Alfred||1962||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|37||Gallant||John P.||1960||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|38||Gentile||Gennaro||1971||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|40||Gibbons||Thomas||1955||Left ministry; deceased 2017|
|41||Giuliano||Anthony||1984||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|43||Gorman||Richard||1982||Removed from ministry; deceased 2018; laicization process pending at death||Credibly Accused|
|45||Harrington||John M.||1945||Deceased 2009|
|46||Harris||Wallace||1972||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|51||Hyland||Raymond||1947||Deceased 1995||Credibly Accused|
|52||Inzeo||Lawrence||1978||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|53||Jeffers||Robert||1954||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|54||Jenik||John (Bishop)||1970||Removed from ministry; allegation found credible and substantiated by archdiocesan Review Board; canonical process pending||Awaiting final canonical or archdiocesan disposition of allegations against them|
|55||Jesselli||Kenneth||1984||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|56||Kavanagh||Charles||1963||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|58||Kelly||Kevin||1956||Left ministry; deceased 2008|
|60||Kihm||Peter||1981||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|61||Kuhl||Morgan||1993||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|62||LaBelle||Ralph||1978||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|64||Lennon||John W.||1955||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2012||Credibly Accused|
|65||Leone||Arthur||1956||Removed from ministry; deceased 2018; laicization process pending at death||Credibly Accused|
|68||Lynch||John J.||1965||Removed from ministry||Credibly Accused|
|69||Maguire||Stephen||1987||Removed from ministry; laicization process pending||Credibly Accused|
|70||Malone||Donald T.||1960||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2012||Credibly Accused|
|72||Manzione||Arthur (Deacon)||1979||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|74||Martin||Patrick H.||1937||Deceased 1983|
|76||Mazza||Albert (Deacon)||1996||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|77||McCarrick||Theodore (Cardinal)||1958||Laicized||Credibly Accused|
|78||McCarthy||James F. (Bishop)||1968||Removed from ministry; canonical process pending||Awaiting final canonical or archdiocesan disposition of allegations against them|
|81||McNeill||Lawrence (Deacon)||1973||Deceased 2006|
|82||Meehan||John||1964||Removed from ministry; allegation found credible and substantiated by archdiocesan Review Board; canonical process pending||Awaiting final canonical or archdiocesan disposition of allegations against them|
|83||Melican||Mortimer||1951||Left ministry; deceased 2002|
|84||Mills||Henry||1988||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|86||Murphy||Arthur E.||1919||Deceased 1959|
|88||O’Brien||Edward J.||1962||Deceased 2002|
|89||O’Brien||William B.||1951||Deceased 2014|
|91||O’Herlihy||Michael||1961||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2013||Credibly Accused|
|92||O’Keefe||John||1972||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|93||Parrakow||Edmond||1968||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|95||Pfeiffer||James||1970||Removed from ministry; deceased 2002||Credibly Accused|
|97||Pipala||Edward A.||1966||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2013||Credibly Accused|
|98||Quigley||Patrick||1981||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2010||Credibly Accused|
|99||Quinn||Lawrence T.||1967||Deceased 2004|
|103||Sardy||John||1980||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|105||Stinner||Francis||1967||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2017||Credibly Accused|
|106||Sullivan||Daniel J. L.||1933||Deceased 1977|
|109||Taylor||Samuel||1982||Removed from ministry; allegation found credible and substantiated by archdiocesan Review Board; laicized; appeal of laicization pending||Awaiting final canonical or archdiocesan disposition of allegations against them|
|110||Theisen||Joseph||1959||Removed from ministry; laicized; deceased 2013||Credibly Accused|
|111||Timone||Donald||1960||Removed from ministry; archdiocesan Review Board process pending||Awaiting final canonical or archdiocesan disposition of allegations against them|
|112||Tos||Aldo||1953||Removed from ministry; deceased 2014; laicization process pending at death||Credibly Accused|
|113||Voglio||John||1987||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
|114||Walsh||James||1936||Deceased 1998||Credibly Accused|
|115||Weckbach||Joseph (Deacon)||1977||Deceased 1995|
|118||White||William T.||1958||Removed from ministry; laicized||Credibly Accused|
Click to view our larger database of accused priests. Here you can search by accused clergy first and last name, Parish/Diocese, city and state, and even by the years of their assignments.
New York Sexual Abuse Lawsuits: News & Updates
Revival windows should stay open so child sex abuse survivors can pursue justice when they are ready, not because window is closing.Click the headline to read more…
Clergy abuse survivor Stephen Mittler is sharing his story and meeting with church officials to encourage transparency from the diocese.Click the headline to read more…
After years of stalled settlement talks, a judge denied the Diocese of Rochester’s injunction request on sexual abuse lawsuits.Click the headline to read more…
The Adult Survivors Act will open a one-year revival window for adult survivors of sexual assault whose claims are currently time-barred.Click the headline to read more…
The Diocese of Albany added Father Gregory Weider to its list of clergy it deems credibly accused of sexual abuse against minors. Click the headline to read more…
A leaked transcript of a call between NY Diocese leaders and their attorneys may point to the real reason an independent program was set up for child clergy sex abuse survivors. Click the headline to read more…
The Diocese of Buffalo is being sued by the state’s Attorney General for the misuse of charitable assets by supporting predatory priests. Click the headline to read more…
A federal bankruptcy Judge sets the deadline for submitting sex abuse claims against the Diocese of Buffalo. Click the headline to read more…
New York’s Child Victims Act revival window has been extended to August 14, 2021. Click the headline to read more…
Taking an approach used by several dioceses outside New York previously, the Diocese of Rochester followed suit and became the first New York Diocese to file for Chapter 11. Click the headline to read more…
Facing over 200 clergy abuse lawsuits, Rockville Centre Diocese filed for bankruptcy protection to help manage legal expenses and facilitate settlements with sexual abuse survivors. Click the headline to read more…
Lawyers for clergy abuse survivors are fighting to make sure the Diocese of Buffalo is properly maximizing property values, the proceeds of which would help fund compensation programs for survivors. Click the headline to read more…
The Diocese of Ogdensburg, which covers the northern part of New York, faces 20 new clergy abuse lawsuits. Click the headline to read more…
In what many believe is a growing effort to limit payouts to sexual abuse survivors, the Diocese of Syracuse files for Bankruptcy. Click the headline to read more…
After nearly three months of courts being closed due to Covid-19, they reopened to a flood of new lawsuits, including over 50 against the Diocese of Albany. Click the headline to read more…
With the reduction of court services, New York’s governor and legislators extended the deadline for filing a childhood sexual abuse claim under the Childs Victim Act. Click the headline to read more…
The Diocese of Buffalo is blaming the Child Victim’s Act, which gives sexual abuse survivors a revival window to file previous expired claims, as the primary reason for filing for bankruptcy. Click the headline to read more…
The judge of the Supreme Court of Erie Country doesn’t dispute compensation should be paid to clergy abuse victims. However, with the Buffalo Diocese filing for bankruptcy protection, delays in payouts are inevitable. Click the headline to read more…
In September of 2019, a former parishioner of Holy Trinity Church, who was also a student as the Holy Trinity School, filed a lawsuit against the Diocese of Buffalo claiming Monsignor Valerio Bernardo, a pastor of Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church and Holy Trinity School, abused her during the late 1960s when she was five years old. Click the headline to read more…
New York Passes Law Opening a “Window” to Allow Previously Expired Claims of Childhood Sexual Abuse to be Filed
In August of 2019, New York legislature passed the Child Victims Act which allows survivors of childhood sexual abuse a one-year window to file a lawsuit against their abusers and the institutions responsible. Click the headline to read more…
With the passing of the Child Victims Act, New York has gone from one of the worst states to one of the best states to file a childhood sexual abuse lawsuit. Click the headline to read more…
While the Diocese of Buffalo is set to pay out $17.5 million to compensate victims of priest molestation, many say it’s not enough. Click the headline to read more…
Three sexual abuse survivors testified in an Albany court that they were abused by more than 80 clergy from the Albany Diocese. Click the headline to read more…